This. This hurt. Dean saying that about the puppy dog eyes. :( Ouch. "My brother could give you these puppy dog eyes and you'd buy right into it." "Just give her the puppy dog thing." Reichenbach [gifset]
I can't decide what my favorite part of this is. God being Dean's father-in-law? Satan his brother-in-law? The fact that that conversation could totally make for a plausible episode? Naw, let's be honest, it's the "when."